Een pleidooi om de eeuwige zoektocht naar abstracte normatieve grondslagen te staken en op zoek te gaan naar de voorwaarden voor het ontstaan en voortbestaan van normatieve systemen vanuit een buitenstaandersperspectief dat conceptuele anayse verbindt met historische en sociologische inzichten. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2020 |
Keywords | Biopolitics, Coronavirus, Rule of law, Foucault, Agamben |
Authors | Lukas van den Berge |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2020 |
Authors | Klaas Rozemond |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2019 |
Keywords | grondslagen, normatief systeem, buitenstaanderperspectief, empirisch perspectief |
Authors | Pauline Westerman |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2019 |
Keywords | interdisciplinariteit, wijsbegeerte van het recht, wetenschapspolitiek, rechtsfilosofie, rechtenstudie |
Authors | Niels Graaf |
AbstractAuthor's information |
De wijsbegeerte van het recht, ooit koningin der rechtswetenschap, is onderdeel geworden van de juridische ‘perspectiefvakken’. Daarmee is het risico ontstaan dat uiteindelijk het ‘perspectiefvak’ dat het beste aansluit bij de wetenschap van het positieve recht (institutioneel) zegeviert. Academische l’art pour l’art in de zin dat een subdiscipline als de wijsbegeerte van het recht zich in een afgeschermde traditie opsluit, moet daarom worden voorkomen. Tegelijkertijd is het zaak dat perspectiefvakken niet alleen hun argumentatie verrijken en schrijven voor een groter lezerspubliek, maar zich ook duidelijker naar de buitenwereld presenteren als niet inwisselbaar, maar complementair. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2019 |
Keywords | migration, exile, citizenship, Europe, Spanish civil war |
Authors | Massimo La Torre |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Exile and migration are once more central issues in the contemporary European predicament. This short article intends to discuss these questions elaborating on the ideas of two Spanish authors, a novelist, Max Aub, and a philosopher, María Zambrano, both marked by the tragic events of civil war and forced expatriation. Exile and migration in their existential perspective are meant as a prologue to the vindication of citizenship. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2017 |
Authors | Marieke Borren |
Author's information |
Opinion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2016 |
Keywords | Geert Wilders, hate speech, freedom of opinion, District Court of The Hague, conviction |
Authors | Jogchum Vrielink |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2016 |
Authors | Marjoleine Zieck |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2015 |
Keywords | drone warfare, politics of international law, humanitarian law, targeted killing |
Authors | Wouter G. Werner |
AbstractAuthor's information |
In this article I discuss one of the latest reports on the practice of drone warfare, the UN SRCT Drone Inquiry. I use the report to illustrate some of the specific forms of legal politics that surround drone warfare today. In the first place, I focus on the tension between the capacity of drones to target more precisely and the never-ending critique that drone warfare victimizes civilian populations. Secondly, I focus on the call for more objective legal rules that can be found in many debates on drone warfare. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2015 |
Authors | Luigi Corrias |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2014 |
Authors | Antony Duff |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2013 |
Authors | Morag Goodwin |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 1 2013 |
Authors | Carel Smith |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 3 2012 |
Keywords | democracy, we, world, self-government, democratic impulse |
Authors | Evert van der Zweerde |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Which human material forms the real basis of a democratic polity, i.e. of the preconditions of a ‘we’ that inhabits a ‘world’? How is a political ‘we’ related to the ‘we’ that is created by systemic processes of subjectivization? These questions presents themselves with new relevance in a ‘globalized’ world, in which democratic spurts and waves spread from other parts of the world to the West, and in which the liberal-democratic rule of law state appears to be undermining its own moral preconditions. The real task ahead is to find out what ‘we’ denotes politically. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 3 2012 |
Keywords | democracy, public sphere, civil society, Arab Spring, feminism |
Authors | Judith Vega |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Steven Winter’s argument is premised on a sharp contrast of individualist and social revolutions. I elaborate my doubts about his argument on three accounts, involving feminist perspectives at various points. First, I take issue with Winter’s portrayal of liberal theory, redirecting the focus of his concern to economic libertarianism rather than liberalism, and arguing a more hospitable attitude to the Kantian pith in the theory of democracy. Secondly, I discuss his conceptualization of democracy, adding the conceptual distinction of civil society and public sphere. Thirdly, I question his normative notion of socially situated selves as having an intrinsic relation to social freedom. I moreover consult cultural history on the gendered symbolics of market and democracy to further problematize Winter’s take on either’s meaning for social freedom. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 3 2012 |
Keywords | Enlightenment universalism, self-governance, freedom, moral point of view, political participation |
Authors | Ronald Tinnevelt |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Winter’s criticism of the conventional account of freedom and democracy is best understood against the background of the history of Enlightenment critique. Winter claims that our current misunderstanding of freedom and self-governance is the result of the strict dichotomy between subject and object. This paper critically reconstructs Winter’s notion of freedom and self-governance which does not adequately address (a) the details of his anti-collectivist claim, and (b) the necessary conditions for the possibility of a moral point of view. This makes it difficult to determine how Winter can distinguish between freedom and lack of freedom, and to assess the limited or radical nature of his critique of Enlightenment universalism. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 3 2012 |
Keywords | globalisation, civic tradition, Enlightenment, free-market economy, autonomy |
Authors | Tinneke Beeckman |
AbstractAuthor's information |
Can globalisation lead to more democracy? And if so, what concept of freedom lies at the basis of this development? The ideal of liberal freedom, supposedly exercised by the autonomous, rational individual is no longer tenable. Finding a new way of interpreting self-rule beyond self-interested choice has become a crucial aspect of regenerating democratic spirit. This paper formulates three comments on Winter’s paper. The first comment concerns the resemblance between the attitudes of consumers and voters. A second comment reflects on the positive heritage of the Enlightenment. A third comment focuses on the recent Tahrir Square protests and reflects on the republican civic tradition. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 3 2012 |
Authors | Steven L. Winter |
Abstract |
In this reply, Steven L. Winter adresses his critics. |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 2 2012 |
Authors | Irina Baraliuc, Sari Depreeuw and Serge Gutwirth |
Author's information |
Discussion |
|
Journal | Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy, Issue 3 2011 |
Authors | Gunther Teubner |
Abstract |
In this concluding article, Gunther Teubner addresses his critics. |